Saturday, December 12, 2020

COLLECTIVIZED SOCIAL SANCTIONING TIME?

All quotes below are from:  HIERARCHY IN THE FORESTTHE EVOLUTION OF EGALITARIAN BEHAVIOR, Christopher Boehm, Harvard University Press, 1999  

Preface p. xii-x.

To one who is living one’s life as a democrat, egalitarianism is a topic that affects not only the head, but the heart.  […] the collective voice of the people continues to be, ultimately powerful.  It is this […] that keeps alive human freedom and human rights […].  […] this type of political stance is quite ancient.

We participate in this type of political leverage […], we exert it because we are suspicious of all governance and wish to limit the powers of those who lead, and may try therefore to rule.  To a democrat the power of centralized government, be it national or local, is a perpetual threat to the personal autonomy of its citizens, and ultimately it is the potential for rebellion by the rank and file that keeps our personal autonomies intact. 

Our earliest precursor, in this respect, may well have been an African ape living some 5 to 7 million years ago.  This vanished ancestral hominoid was likely to have formed political coalitions that enabled the rank and file, those who otherwise would have been utterly subordinated, to whittle away at the powers of the alpha individuals whose regular practice was to bully them. 

[…] in holding onto their personal autonomies, the collective weapon of the rank and file has been their ability to define their own social life in moral terms, and to back up their thoughts about political parity with pointed actions in the form of collectivized social sanctioning. 

 

2 comments:

Bob said...

This is probably worth reading! Boehm's "Moral Origins" helped me understand that H. sapiens could indeed pull off an egalitarian society (with effort and constant vigilance of course).

Tom Jablonski said...

So far so good! Searching for a map away from letting the bully's run things. Might be something to get pointed in the right direction.